Comparison of Estimated Costs:
New High School vs. Renovated High School

Below is an estimated comparison between renovating the high school and building a new high school. Both scenarios include adding an elementary school for future growth. The elementary school would either be renovated from the current middle school or built new. Both scenarios result in about the same capacity of students but significantly different costs.

SCENARIO 1 - NEW HIGH SCHOOLCapacity
1. Renovate existing HS to MS for 700 students:
      Concept: 6-8 MS w/ alwnc for growth
Code compliance/update piece$4,500,000
New Gym (Concept: pres gym=café; pres café=MPR, gym=new constr)$950,000
New Classrooms (12)$3,000,000
Other transformations$500,000
Sub-Total $8,950,000
Project Cost (35%)$2,607,500
Total New MS $11,557,500 700
2. Convert existing MS into ES for 450:
Plumbing renovations$200,000
Other transformations, including exits$500,000
            Sub-Total $700,000
Project Cost$200,000
Total Renov ES $900,000 1350 incl MW & MO
3. Build new High School on new site:
Site acquisition $750,000
Site construction
Water & septic $1,750,000
Athletic fields $2,200,000
Building construction
900 stdts x 225 ft2/stu x $90/ft2 $18,225,000
Sub-Total $22,925,000
Project Cost (35%) $7,761,250
Total new HS $30,686,250 900
TOTALS - SCENARIO 1: $43,143,750 2950
SCENARIO 2 - RENOVATE HIGH SCHOOL
1. Renovate existing HS to HS for 850/1000 stdnts:
Plan of March 1999 $19,724,705 850
2. No change to existing MS (6-8):750
3. Construct a new ES for 450 stdnts:
Site construction
Water & septic $900,000
Playgrnd, landscaping $100,000
Building construction
450 stdts x 115 ft2/stu x $80/ft2 $4,140,000
Sub-Total $5,140,000
Project Cost (35%) $1,799,000
Total New ES $6,939,000 1350 incl MW & MO
TOTALS - SCENARIO 2: $26,663,705 2950

Below is an estimated comparison of school capacity based on the above scenarios. Note that the projected capacities are well below 225 per class and the total number of additional students represented by 225 per class.

STUDENT POPULATION:
Present: Current: Regrade: Current: Projected
in 2008:
Projected @ 225
per grade level:
K-4 843 K-5 1023 1183 1315
5-8 786 6-8 606 603 675
9-12 680 9-12 680 729 900
2309 2309 2515 2890


OROL Home CommonsCommons SchoolsSchools NewsstandNewsstand LibraryLibrary Voting BoothVoting Booth SoapboxSoapbox

Last update on 25-May-99 at 9:59 PM.

http://www.orol.org/schools/orhs/issues/space/plan1999/compare_new.html

This page is edited by David K. Taylor. Please send questions or comments to editor@orol.org.